"Nuclear Explosions Wiped Out an Extraterrestrial Civilization"—The Mystery of Mars Sparks Debate
![]() |
| Mars (conceptual image) |
"Nuclear Explosions Wiped Out an Extraterrestrial Civilization"—The Mystery of Mars Sparks Debate
Plasma physicist John Brandenburg presents a theory about Mars: extraterrestrial beings once lived on the Red Planet, only to be wiped out. His hypothesis suggests that a civilization constructed monuments on our neighboring planet before nuclear explosions obliterated them.
In a 2014 paper published in the *Journal of Cosmology*, Brandenburg presented evidence—drawn from the chemical composition of Mars and what he claims are archaeological remnants—arguing that these are signs of a planetary massacre. According to a report by *Popular Mechanics* (reviewed by *AlArabiya.net*), Brandenburg contends that humanity should investigate this matter, as we could potentially face the same danger.
Naturally, both the editorial standards of the journal and Brandenburg’s theory itself have faced criticism from other scientists. The crucial question remains: does the explanation he offers actually align with the measurements he presents?
![]() | |
| Mars (iStock) |
Even setting aside the hypothesis of an alleged attack, another question arises: if a civilization once flourished somewhere within our solar system—only to vanish billions of years before our modern era of exploration and research—what, if anything, would remain of it? Could a rover be sent to traverse a former habitat without ever realizing the truth of what once existed there?
Nuclear Explosions
Brandenburg—who did not respond to requests for an interview—argues that evidence has already been found suggesting the occurrence of nuclear explosions in the Martian atmosphere, pointing specifically to measurements of xenon gas on the Red Planet.
Xenon exists in several forms known as "isotopes," which differ in the number of neutrons within their atoms. Dr. Timothy Swindle—a professor and director emeritus at the University of Arizona’s Lunar and Planetary Laboratory—explains that radioactive decay and radiation-induced reactions can alter this composition. If an explosion were responsible for the presence of xenon on Mars, scientists would expect to find these isotopes in specific proportions.
| Mars (iStock) |
Chemical Evidence
Furthermore, Brandenburg highlights an unusually high ratio of the isotope xenon-129 in the Martian atmosphere, noting that nuclear explosions can produce this isotope. He also points to a higher ratio of argon-40 to argon-36 on Mars compared to Earth, suggesting that Mars received an anomalous surplus of argon-40 as a result of an explosion. Counterarguments
In contrast, Dr. Timothy Swindle—a professor and director emeritus at the Lunar and Planetary Laboratory at the University of Arizona—argues that nuclear fission does not produce the four xenon isotopes that Brandenburg cites as evidence of a match. Furthermore, regarding the heavier isotopes that *are* produced by fission, the data do not align at all; for the isotope xenon-136, Brandenburg’s model predicts a quantity 50% greater than what has actually been measured on Mars.
![]() |
| Space Studies |
Brandenburg’s hypothesis relies on a shift toward lighter fission products, which would imply a gradual decrease in the abundance of xenon isotopes as one moves from the heavier ones (131, 132, 134, and 136). However, his model predicts higher quantities of these heavy isotopes—meaning the discrepancy in the data runs directly counter to his own logic. The presence of xenon-129 can be explained naturally through the radioactive decay of iodine-129 during an early stage of Martian history.
Flawed Logic Regarding Argon
The high ratio of argon on Mars is simply due to the fact that the planet contains a very small amount of argon-36 (only 2% of the amount of argon-36 found on Earth, per gram)—not because an explosion caused an excess of argon-40. In fact, Mars contains a smaller total amount of argon-40 than Earth does.
A 2024 study by Dr. Oliver Shorttle and his colleagues reveals that celestial bodies, which repeatedly collided with Mars during its early stages—within the first 200 to 300 million years of its existence—effectively stripped lighter xenon isotopes from the planet's atmosphere. This natural process altered the balance of the remaining isotopes, accounting for much of what is observed today without the need for any nuclear intervention.



Leave a Comment